You just found a classic album in a crate at a garage sale, or maybe you’re pulling a favorite off your own shelf to sell online. The cover looks clean, and the vinyl is shiny. You might think, “This is in great shape!” But in the world of vinyl collecting, “great shape” isn’t a feeling — vinyl record grading is a standard.
Vinyl record grading is the most critical skill a collector or reseller can master. It’s the universal language that determines whether a record is worth $5 or $500, and without an accurate grade, you’re only guessing at its actual value. This guide explains how to grade records like a professional using industry-standard techniques and the well-established Goldmine Grading Scale. Once you’ve mastered the process, you can confidently use our Value Guide to price your collection with absolute accuracy.
Vinyl is a physical format, and unlike a digital file that plays the same way every time, a record’s condition changes with use. Every fingerprint, scuff, or speck of dust affects sound quality.
Trust: Your grade represents your reputation. If you sell a “Near Mint” record and it arrives noisy or scratched, you risk losing a customer permanently.
Value: Two copies of the same album can differ drastically in price. A rare Beatles pressing may sell for $1,000 in Near Mint condition and under $50 if graded Good.
Communication: Grading standards allow collectors and sellers to describe a record objectively without misunderstandings.
In the U.S. — and on major platforms like Discogs — the Goldmine Standard is the accepted grading system. It provides a consistent framework for evaluating both vinyl and sleeves.
Below is the complete breakdown, from flawless to unplayable.
The Myth of Perfection.
The Vinyl: Perfect in every way. Unplayed and likely never removed from the sleeve. A sealed record may qualify, though sealed copies can still warp or react chemically inside the jacket over time.
The Jacket: Absolutely pristine — no writing, dings, or discoloration.
Pro Tip: Many sellers avoid using “Mint” unless they personally opened the record.
The High Standard for Collectors.
The Vinyl: Nearly flawless with no visible wear. Playback should be silent with no surface noise.
The Jacket: No creases, splits, folds, or cut-outs.
Verdict: If it looks newly purchased under bright light, it’s likely Near Mint.
The Sweet Spot.
The Vinyl: Light scuffs or faint hairlines allowed, but nothing that affects listening. Minor background noise may appear in the lead-in or between tracks.
The Jacket: Slight ring wear or light corner wear is acceptable.
Verdict: A VG+ record is clean, well-kept, and ideal for most collectors.
The Listener’s Grade.
The Vinyl: Noticeable surface noise, especially in quiet sections. Light scratches may cause occasional pops or clicks.
The Jacket: Visible wear, seam splitting, writing, or faded ring wear.
Verdict: VG records are fine for playing but less desirable for collectors.
The “It Plays Through” Grade.
The Vinyl: Heavy scuffs, surface noise, and popping are expected, but the record should not skip.
The Jacket: Major wear, staining, seam splits, or writing.
Verdict: Great filler copies for rare titles, but not collector-quality.
The End of the Line.
Condition: Cracked, warped, skipping, or deeply scratched vinyl. Jackets may be moldy, torn, or water-damaged.
Value: Typically worthless except for wall art or creative repurposing.
Knowing the categories is only the beginning. Professional graders follow a consistent inspection process to ensure accuracy and fairness.
A dim room hides defects.
Inspect the vinyl surface.
Gloss: A glossy, shiny surface suggests minimal play. A dull gray tone indicates groove wear.
Scuffs vs. Scratches:
Warps: Check for edge warps or bowl-shaped dish warps by laying the vinyl on a flat surface.
Spindle marks reveal how often a record has been played.
The runout (dead wax) contains etched identifiers that help confirm the correct pressing.
Evaluate the jacket separately.
For records priced at $20 or more, a playtest is recommended.
Play grading removes uncertainty and reinforces trust with buyers.
Even experienced graders overlook key details. Avoid these pitfalls:
“EX” is not part of the Goldmine scale. Stick to the official terms — especially VG+.
When in doubt, downgrade. Over-grading damages credibility, while under-grading earns positive reviews.
Always clean before grading. Dust causes false noise and hides surface quality.
Original printed sleeves add value and must be noted in the grade.
| Grade | Symbol | Vinyl Condition | Sleeve Condition | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mint | M/SS | Perfect | Perfect | Archival collectors |
| Near Mint | NM | Like new | No wear | Audiophiles |
| Very Good Plus | VG+ | Light scuffs | Minor wear | Most collectors |
| Very Good | VG | Noticeable wear | Visible ring wear | Casual listening |
| Good / Good+ | G/G+ | Heavy noise | Major wear | Collection fillers |
| Poor / Fair | P/F | Skips, cracked | Damaged | Wall art |
The difference between grades is exponential, not linear. A 1960s rock album might sell at:
Spotting a true VG+ versus VG can dramatically impact your pricing.
Grading takes practice, but mastering the process gives you confidence, protects your reputation, and leads to more accurate pricing. Use bright lighting, follow the Goldmine definitions closely, and be honest about every defect you see or hear.
Once you know the grade, you’re ready to determine real-world value.
Visit our Vinyl Record Value Guide to look up prices based on your grade.
Sign up for exclusive offers, original stories, events, and more.
